Vital Football

Latest York City News

City have past history with Shields

City have past history with Shields

York City have already met their next FA Cup opponents South Shields on three occasions - and always away from home.

The most recent of those was a first round tie in January 1969, when York secured their biggest victory on the road in the competition - 6-0 courtesy of a Tommy Ross hat-trick and further strikes from Ted MacDougall (2) and Gerry Baker (pen).

That contest was played in front of a 6,000 attendance and allowed the visitors a second round home game against non-league Morecambe, with the prolific MacDougall claiming another brace in a 2-0 win.

Over 11,000 expectant fans then packed into Bootham Crescent the following January as top-flight Stoke City, including England's World Cup-winning goalkeeper Gordon Banks, eventually overcame gallant York 2-0 in the third round.

Despite those valiant efforts, City had otherwise too long regularly massively underachieved, and were disastrously forced into making a third successive re-application to the Football League at the end of that particular campaign.

York had also been much less successful in terms of the FA Cup just three years earlier, when a Paul Aimson penalty was their only consolation in a shock 3-1 first round defeat at Shields - with 7,000 the recorded gate. City were actually relegated from the Third Division at the end of that season after finishing bottom of the table.

The first-ever trip to South Shields arose in December 1957, a second round affair that the visitors won 3-1 after goals from a rather unfamiliar name from that era, John Robertson, plus legendary marksmen Norman Wilkinson and Arthur Bottom. That tie was overseen by an incredible 18,500 supporters.

Brave cup-fighters City were next up against top-flight Birmingham City, who had actually been defeated in the final by Manchester City just eighteen months earlier. With the original game postponed due to a waterlogged pitch, the two teams bizarrely lined-up on a Wednesday afternoon at Bootham Crescent.

The unusual start certainly didn't effect the attendance, however, with 19,750 hugely excited fans soon witnessing former England goalkeeper Gil Merrick blocking Billy Fenton's thirteenth-minute shot and the predatory Bottom smashing in the rebound.

Just a couple of minutes later, Ron Spence's free-kick was fired home by inside-left Peter Wragg to double the advantage; while another set-piece, this time delivered by right-winger Billy Hughes, was headed into the roof of the net by Wilkinson as the half-hour mark approached.

A truly sensational 3-0 result from magnificent York, celebrated by their joyous fans giving a stirring rendition of 'The Happy Wanderer' theme that had so characterised City's own incredible run into the semi-finals only three years earlier.

Having completed their biggest-ever victory over top-flight opponents, City were next paired with already three-times FA Cup winners Bolton Wanderers; and 23,600 spectators packed into the Crescent for a tight scoreless encounter, with the favourites eventually prevailing 3-0 in the replay.

After narrowly avoiding that mighty scare against battling York, First Division Bolton were actually to take the trophy for a fourth time that year by beating Manchester United 2-0 at Wembley, with England's Nat Lofthouse scoring both of their goals.

Video Link: GoldenOldiesOn45RPM

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Vital York City
Date:Monday September 18 2017
Time: 3:00PM

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Recent York City Articles

Video: Little Aidan's big challenge

Weekend goalscorer Aidan Connolly is hoping his injury woes are now firmly behind him having recently returned to favour at York City.

Rewind Extra: Billy's final lament

It's back to November 2007 and a popular outgoing manager expressing his deep regret at leaving Bootham Crescent.

City Futsal hold top-six ranking

York City Futsal's second victory in three games witnesses them currently ranked as the sixth best team in the country.

Video: Salford City 3 York City 2

New manager Martin Gray was given further evidence of the task in front of him when witnessing a first defeat in charge of York City.

Archived Vital York Articles

Vital York articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Should Alex Whittle remain first-choice left-back?
Suggested By: Vital York City
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent York City Results (view all)

York City Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

2.tomrossbass 1
Write for Vital Football